They are beautiful! This is about my 6th pair of Grandco sandals. I have never had this happen before and have bought on line at least once before. Usually try to buy in store.
The right fits perfectly. The strap around the top of the foot is 7 3/4 inches. The left foot the strap is 8 1/8 inches which makes it too loose. I can wear them, but they aren't as comfortable and don't look as nice on my foot because of the gap - sort of hold it on by scrintching my toes. I didn't return as I'm not sure that the next pair wouldn't be the same and also needed them for an event I was going to attend.